Friday, August 31, 2007

Thunderdome

In my version of Thunderdome, six page ideas go in, and one page idea comes out. Let's see how y'all do prioritizing the following six possible pages we could build/improve:

1) Reviewer's Ratings Page. Right now it only shows 5-star movies. When you look at your Friends, you see all their ratings. What if you saw all a reviewer's ratings, along with being able to look at a variety of slices through them (again, as with Friends): their 5-star, 4-star, etc. movies, the movies you have in common, and so on)

2/3) Split the Reviews & Lists page into two pages -- one dedicated to Reviews and one for Top 10 Lists. This would make it far more logical when you select a Top 10 List and land on page - you'd see what you select opened up, presented clearly, instead of hunting for them. Space would be used better on both pages to separate these.

4) Outward Profile page. You've got an inward facing profile page where you can change your avatar and nickname. What if we put back the "personal statements" and then create an OUTWARD facing profile page -- the page that summarizes each Friend or reviewer, with key highlights and movie tastes, and so on.

5) Members Similar to You. One page full of similar members -- like that block of 4 on the community home page, but expanded.

6) Top 10 Lists page. Again, like the little block on the community home page, but with lots of these -- new ones, popular ones, etc.

(Let's tweak the stakes a bit, and say for the sake of argument that we'll only be able to do 3 of them, and that each page would take two weeks of effort.)

Finally, don't just think of superusers - like yourselves -- but what is good for other people, maybe who don't use the site as deeply or fluently as you do. Making the existing site easier is valued highly.

Can ya'll come to a consensus and convince each other of a single #1 option?

43 comments:

  1. I think it's possible to "extract" an idea of someone's movie taste by looking at their 5-star rating only. I've rated more than 1,500 movies, and I pity anyone who'd be presented with all of them. I don't much care for the Top 10 lists (they all seem to be the same lists whenever I log on) and the "other members like you"-section has so far only disappointed me. These people who are supposedly like me, do not rate like I do, that's for sure. The outward profile thing sounds like an idea, but then Netflix starts looking a bit like a dating site, doesn't it? :-P

    ReplyDelete
  2. My top 3 would be, in order:

    5) Members Similar to You: Because the most important thing Netflix can do is help us find more movies we will actually like.

    6) Top 10 Lists page: Because lists can also be a good source for more movies, and also it would be good to be able to find the "popular" lists. Just looking at random lists all the time is often unproductive.

    2/3) Split the Reviews & Lists page: Making it easier to make and maintain lists sounds like a pretty good thing. Not sure if this is a good or bad idea, but how about a "sound bite" review? For every movie we could select a 2-4 word phrase that summed up the movie for us: "Movie of the Year", "All Flash, No Substance", "Bad, just Bad", etc.

    Expanding our personal pages sounds fine, but I'm not sure how many people really want to spend time writing up descriptions of themselves. So, #4 seems lower priority to me. Though it might be cool if you could come up with a questionaire with 10-20 multiple choice questions that people could fill out in a couple minutes to give others a a feel for them. Not sure what those questions/choices should be though.

    As for #1, I'm against it happening at all unless its opt-in.

    ReplyDelete
  3. How do you do it? You're wearing US out! Don't you have some mugs to rinse? Will try to tackle this sensibly anon, but in the meantime have a great weekend, and thanks for all your great and apparently tireless work.

    ReplyDelete
  4. My 1st choice would be the Top 10 Lists, I enjoy checking those out and am sure that there are more of them then just the ones I've seen on my community start page and while browsing movies.

    2nd choice would be #5-people with similar tastes. I've run across a few movies to add to my q from checking out their info.

    ReplyDelete
  5. My top two choices are #1 and #6. I find the Top 10 Lists extremely helpful for finding movies that fit into interesting themes or groups, so anything that can be done to make browsing through them even easier would be much appreciated.

    As for the reviewer's ratings page, what I'd like to see at the top is a list of all the movies that both that particular reviewer and I have rated, so that I can easily compare our ratings, rather than having to first scroll through a list of movies that are primarily ones that only they have rated. Those movies could appear below the list of common-rated movies, but I think it might be helpful to be able to easily compare ratings so that users could get a better sense of why exactly it is that other members are so similar to them.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I actually started writing my choices out on paper, then saw that Baff had the same order and choices I did. So I'll note mine briefly with reasons.

    5.) Members Similar to You: I like this simply because 1.)It's helped me remember movies I have seen, and 2.) gives (so far) great ideas of what to see next. The only thing I might add to the page that displays would be a drop down "Sort by" list. With the ability to sort by Genre and/or ratings.

    6.) Top 10 Lists Page: The only thing I could add to improve top 10 lists would be if you could bundle them based on "Members Similar to You".

    2/3.) Split the Reviews and Lists page: Just because they are two completely different beasts.

    Things to perhaps work into these would be to expand on the personalization of each.

    Factor in the "Most like You" algorithm for the "Reviews" that will show on each members "review" page, and the same for "Top 10 Lists". This would create an easier environment for "newbies", whether to Netflix or just Internet in general.

    Most folks don't want to have to think too hard.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I agree with knaldskalle regarding the "other members like you" stuff. Even those with 80+% similarity to me don't watch the same movies I do or rate them the way I do. I just realized that none of the features on the community pages have helped me find a new movie. Not my own friends, not the 10 top lists, not the members with similar tastes to you. Heck, even Movies You'll Love can only give me two suggestions (I've rated 1638 movies). Maybe if the "members similar to you" was expanded more, I would see what exactly it is that Netflix thinks we have in common?

    ReplyDelete
  8. This is probably a moment too late and just occurred to me as I read your list: Until a year or two ago there was a page attached to each film showing the ten or so films most liked by those who'd enjoyed that one. It was eliminated, but, for me, that list was more helpful than similar members or member lists.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Although I like the idea of a whole page of "other members like you" I have to admit that #1 is my pick. Why? It's frustrating not being able to see all ratings of a particular member. I want to know what they hated at least as much as what they loved, because this is just as important in deciding, for example, friend compatibility.

    #1 top vote
    #5 second place

    ReplyDelete
  10. #1 Reviewer's Ratings Page:
    This to me is far above the rest in importance. It's frustrating that once I find someone who I truly agree with... I can't really get much information about them at all. This is because many people don't write a lot of reviews and you can only see 5-star ratings. If someone rates like me, their 4-star movies should be spectacular, so I want to know about that. If I'm curious about a movie, but don't know if it's worth watching, I might check how my favorite reviewer rated it -- rent it if 3 or above, don't rent if 2 or lower. There are so many reasons this is a great feature. As someone above pointed out, being able to see "movies in common" is a much more effective way to determine actual similarity to you and if you care about their opinion. It tells me a lot if they rate one of my favorite movies 1 or 2 stars. Also, people use the rating scale in different ways -- I could see right away that I should hold on to a reviewer who gave 4-stars to all my 5-star films and 3-stars to all my 4-star films, as we clearly like and dislike the same things, but just use a different scale to express it. Anyway, I'm going to stop babbling on about how great this would be and just say that I think it would be the single best thing you could do to allow Netflix users to benefit from each-other's movie viewing experience. It would make saving favorite reviews an infinitely more valuable feature.

    #6 Top Ten Lists Page:
    The lists are great, but right now it's very difficult to find lists that interest me. The block on the community page hardly ever changes, and I always wish I could page through more. It would also be cool to see popular lists. It would be awesome if you could search lists, for example, type in "horror" or "cinematography" and you get a listing of all member lists which have that word in the title or list summary/description.

    The rest of the ideas all sound good, but none of them stick out as being must-haves. Splitting reviews and lists into separate pages would probably look nicer, but it doesn't really give us anything we don't already have. The outward profile page is intriguing, but I'm not sure I completely understand what this would be. I guess I'd have to go with #5 Members Similar to You, because I often find that "similar" members aren't actually that similar (or at least as far as I can tell, which isn't too well since #1 hasn't been implemented yet hint, hint)... so having more people to shuffle through would help me in finding truly similar members.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Here's what I want to do:
    1.Find members similar to me.
    2.View their ratings and reviews of movies I have not rated.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I certainly understand everyone's desire to see everyone else's personal info, but I think it would be an incredibly bad idea for Netflix to implement #1.

    If its implemented without an opt-in system, they would just be begging to be sued or at the very least some extremely bad press from privacy advocates. This would do more damage than good.

    If it is implemented as opt-in, the vast majority of people would probably never be aware of the option and so only a small percent of people would have all their ratings open to the public.

    Either way, it doesn't really seem worth the effort to me.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I believe that, legally, Netflix has the right to do whatever they want with the ratings users give. It is not private account information, giving ratings is entirely optional, and ratings are in no way tied to the service being paid for (as opposed to rental history, which is tied to the service, and is illegal to expose).

    I can understand that some users may prefer to keep their ratings private. I see no reason why people shouldn't be allowed to opt-out of having their ratings public.

    ReplyDelete
  14. "I believe that, legally, Netflix has the right to do whatever they want with the ratings users give."

    It may be legal, but that doesn't make it the right thing to do.

    "It is not private account information"

    It should be.

    "giving ratings is entirely optional"

    Irrelevant

    "and ratings are in no way tied to the service being paid for (as opposed to rental history, which is tied to the service, and is illegal to expose)."

    Not sure what you are trying to say here. Netflix says "Rate movies to get recommendations." I've never seen them say "Rate movies so that we can publish your viewing habits to anyone curious."

    "I can understand that some users may prefer to keep their ratings private. I see no reason why people shouldn't be allowed to opt-out of having their ratings public."

    Opt-out is not acceptable. It is currently set up as an opt-in system, Friends. Just because you are curious about my viewing habits doesn't mean you have the right to see them. If you want to see them, ask and I will decide.

    ReplyDelete
  15. My #1 would be an expanded "Member Similar to You" page.

    A little ot, but I'd LOVE for the five star rating system to be expanded. There's a HUGE chasm between "I didn't like it" and "I liked it". Maybe half stars? or a sixth star at abou the "meh, it was ok" mark?

    ReplyDelete
  16. THIS is the best idea I've read on the topic so far:

    "Anonymous said...
    Here's what I want to do:
    1.Find members similar to me.
    2.View their ratings and reviews of movies I have not rated."

    I'll second that.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Sort by Release Date of Movie in Theaters and not release date of movie in netflix. This would be useful for watch now movies.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I agree with Amanda that being able to see more than just the 5 star ratings would allow us to create a significantly more dependable short list of 'fave' (mercy!) reviewers. But Baff is also right that we've to date we've been renting and rating movies believing that we were doing so with complete anonymity and confidentiality, and suddenly there's talk of people being able to rummage through all this laundry at will. So, important question, Michael : to what extent would the existing privacy option keep people invisible if they wanted to remain so? That would certainly help me, at least, prioritize these options.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I agree with everyone here that I want to see:

    #5 Members similiar to me, but there should be certain criteria for it, for example at least 60% similiarities. I also agree that there should expand the ratings 19 1/2 increments because a lot of reciews I have read said they would have given it 1/2 a star, but since they can't they either drop it down or push it up.

    #6 The top 10 list is a great idea.

    #2/3 would make it easier to find information you want since it is seperated.

    ReplyDelete
  20. RE: Thunderdome

    For me the "Members Like You" section is useless without being able to see all of the members ratings. 5 star ratings alone offer too generic a picture of that member's tastes. All About Eve, Citizen Kane, Schindler's List, Taxi Driver; these films appear on members' lists that only bear a 40% similarity to me. It is the ratings that fall from 1-4 stars that really tell me about that member's tastes. This, in turn, allows me to decide if exploring their "Lists" would be beneficial. In my mind these 3 items only work well as features when presented thoroughly on an individual level and then used together.

    Separating the reviews from the lists would only be useful for me if the individual pages contained additional scrolls to give us more variety. Example: The lists page could contain three scrolls. One for most helpful/popular lists, one for most recently added and one for "Netflix staff picks their favorite lists". The same could then be done on the reviews page.

    The "Outward Profile" sounds fun. However, unless I can add a "Favorite Reviewer" (for example) instead of digging them up on the site every few weeks, this feature will mainly appeal to the "look at me" crowd.

    I know this response is less "Thunderdome" and more "Mexican Stand-off" but I hope my response will offer some insight into how I use this terrific site. For me it is much more than a place to queue up movies for rental. Thanks for all your dedication and keep up the great work!

    JayMikey in Baltimore

    ReplyDelete
  21. "So, important question, Michael : to what extent would the existing privacy option keep people invisible if they wanted to remain so?"

    I would add to that the question of what happens with inactive accounts? I assume that they remain visible to us. Millions of people would be completely unaware that there was anything to opt-out of.

    ReplyDelete
  22. "For me the "Members Like You" section is useless without being able to see all of the members ratings. 5 star ratings alone offer too generic a picture of that member's tastes."

    I don't think they are allowed to reveal all of a user's ratings because of that legal issue that prevents a company from sharing a viewer's rental habits.

    ReplyDelete
  23. "I don't think they are allowed to reveal all of a user's ratings because of that legal issue that prevents a company from sharing a viewer's rental habits."

    Netflix believes it would be legal because they would be linking the information to our Netflix user names, rather than to our real names.

    ReplyDelete
  24. michael, from netflixSeptember 2, 2007 at 1:12 PM

    Baff is correct. Because rating history is different from rental history, and because the information is only attached to an anonymous profile (and because you can opt out entirely by "not participating in community features") the decision of whether to show only 5-star ratings, or more, is purely a gut call.

    ReplyDelete
  25. reviewers ratings page
    members similar to you
    reviews page

    my personal pref:
    reviewers ratings page
    reviews
    outward profile (i liked it)

    ReplyDelete
  26. I would like to see the outward profile page developed a little more. This will give me more insight as to what other viewers like in a movie and I can evaluate the similarities and differences when making a movie choice outside of my normal range.
    I want to know why other viewers like and dislike movies, and the outward profile page will help.

    ReplyDelete
  27. How do we let people know that you cannot let Customer Service know an issue unless you call them? Mentioning the problem with a movie in the review does not do any good to solve the issue?
    Please, report the problem online or call customer service.

    ReplyDelete
  28. @Baff and others who are concerned about the privacy issues at hand:
    I don't want to give the impression that I don't have any concern for privacy issues. But I find it difficult to understand why someone would want to keep their ratings private when no one could possibly know who you are. The profiles, as Michael pointed out, are entirely anonymous (unless you choose to make your nickname your real name). I couldn't ask you, personally, for permission to view your ratings if I wanted to... because I have no idea who you are... and that's how it should be. All I need to know is that I respect your opinions on film and would like to enrich my own movie-watching by benefiting from your experience.

    Also, Friends is an opt-in experience because private, personal, and confidential information is made available to your friends -- your real name, rental history, what's in your queue, etc. Participating in Community features by having a public profile is an opt-out experience, because no personal information is shared and it is completely anonymous. And if you do decide to participate in Community features, what better way to do so than by facilitating others' ability to enjoy the same movies you do?

    And to answer your question about inactive accounts, I would guess that you cannot see their profiles. I'm basing this on the fact that I have a friend who disappears entirely from my friends list every time her account goes inactive, and then she pops back on as soon as she re-enlists.

    ReplyDelete
  29. I don't use my real name, but I have seen plenty of others who have. I do however use a nickname that I use everywhere on the net as I am sure many others do too.

    If Netflix were to put our credit card info up on our public pages, how confident would people feel about being "entirely anonymous" behind their nickname.

    I assure you that we are most certainly not "entirely anonymous". I would guess that a huge number of people have given out their nickname to coworkers and such. Lots of people even post it on websites. They gave it out knowing that their 1-4 star movies are not visible to anyone who looks.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Baff, I believe this is an opt-in system, generally speaking (and Michael correct me if I'm wrong): The only way you can be seen is if you are a Friend (which is opt-in) or a Reviewer (which I would say is opt-in), or soon as a Fave (which is opt-in). If you don't want anyone to see you, don't use the system. There won't be any links to you. I think this is clever, actually. It isn't that you can opt-in to being seen, but you can totally opt in to this Community - simply by participation. If that isn't enough - you can STILL opt out. How much protection do you need? AND your anonymous! I think this is safe and simple. I'm not entirely sure what your issue is.

    ReplyDelete
  31. 1. (#6) A much bigger selection of lists, cross-sectionable by sim%/genre/subject matter/hair color of leads (just testing), etc. Right now they often seem rather arbitrary, and I actually got very similar results from my old system of getting my pet monkey throw darts at my movie encyclopedia with a fan riffling through the pages (no offense).
    ________________

    2. (#1) Access to all of a reviewers' ratings -- although I'm on Baff's embattled side here, and think it's something that we should have to opt-IN to rather than than opt-OUT of to safeguard our heretofore presumption of renting and rating invisibility (however silly other people might find that; let's try to respect each other's sensibilities). But if it's only by opting-in that we can, in all fairness, gain access to other people's info, then the more serious (ergo valuable?) raters will surely want to come out and play rather than skulk indoors all alone, however shy they might be.

    3. (#5) A proper list of similar members. Although I'd imagine that this spin-the-bottle quartet would be much more entertaining to casual users (the vast majority of members?), and by bookmarking the one's I like I already have a nice list of my own (and thanks for all your wonderful gems, guys).

    4/5. (#2/3) I've never quite understood why you even have those 5 latest reviews on that first page instead of just having lists on page 1 and then going directly to the 10 reviews on page 2, but it doesn't really bother me how it is now if it's going to take a lot of valuable person-hrs to separate them and then test them across all platforms and browsers.

    6. (#4). The less I know about someone the more objectively I can read their reviews (especially if I know that the separation of Church and Movies has been violated). But have no problem with a bio being there if people want them back; I just won't read them, thanks all the same.

    ReplyDelete
  32. If you don't want anyone to see you, don't use the system.

    That is precisely the problem. I have two options; 1) opt in and put all of my ratings -and God knows what else will come down the pike later- on display for every Netflix member who cares to look, or 2) exclude myself from writing reviews in order to keep information that I never intended to share with anyone but my friends private.

    I joined Netflix because I love movies and writing about movies. If I write and post a review, that's fair game. I DID NOT join Netflix to have my rental history spewed out for all to see. I don't have an issue with my friends seeing all of that. I would most likely answer any questions about what I have rented and liked (or not) of anyone who asked. What I do not care for at all is having the "all or nothing" approach to this that Netflix is taking. Want to write a review, Great! Then we are going to show everything about you to everyone! Sorry, No more reviews from me, in spite of the fact that all of this is supposed to increase participation. I've marked preference I an possibly find "private" and will be strongly considering canceling my membership if this "let's all share everything" continues to be pushed at the expense of privacy.

    ReplyDelete
  33. anon - Your comments feel misguided and reactive. You said "Then we are going to show everything about you to everyone!" and I"m just not seeing that in the original post nor even the comments here. The information we see about reviewers is not that invasive (5-star ratings, your reviews and a nickname); I show my friends my REAL name, my rental history, my queue, all my ratings... There is no comparison. Some people are here in the comments arguing that it's better to show all ratings, and you're arguing that you want to stop contributing your reviews because -- why? because you don't mind your 5-stars showing, but showing more is aggregious? I'm just not seeing what is causing you such a strong reaction. Yes, it seems either/or here, but the opt-in state still isn't that exposing. Have you used MySpace? Twitter? Facebook? This Netflix community experiment is cool, but doesn't come close to the exposure you get in any "real" social network. This is disneyland. You can pretend it is scary, but I cannot imagine what ill could come from any of this, as it has been described.

    ReplyDelete
  34. for me, #1 is
    - Members Similar to You - by far

    ReplyDelete
  35. @anon. As I and some others mentioned earlier, it wouldn't have to be all or nothing. Participating in community features (by having a public profile) would just opt you in to showing all ratings by default. If Netflix sets it up as such, you could still opt-out, specifically, of showing all ratings if that really bothers you.

    ReplyDelete
  36. @Anon. I share some of your possibly irrational but nonetheless strongly felt concerns about the increasing intrusion on our 'personal space', but I think we can take Netflix at their word as regards the Privacy Setting, which states very clearly:

    "Select 'Private' below to prevent members from seeing your anonymous profile and movie ratings".

    It doesn't mention reviews, which would obviously still be viewable on the movie pages, just not collected together on a review page since there wouldn't be a 'See anon's other reviews' to click on, so wouldn't get all those additional votes from your 'fans' :(

    ReplyDelete
  37. Have you used MySpace? Twitter? Facebook?

    No, I have not used any of those. Not interested and never have been. Nice try, though.

    ReplyDelete
  38. 1) Split the Reviews & Lists page

    Because I use them but they need to be separate.

    2) Members Similar to You (as opt-in)

    I’ve been finding both movies I haven’t rated and movies I want to rent. It is a much more productive way of finding those unrated movies. I love the side by side comparison.

    3) Outward Profile page. (as opt-in)

    Because I want it.

    I don’t like the top lists as presented on the community page. Unless they have an odd or catchy title there is no way to gauge their usefulness without clicking. Plus they don’t change, or haven’t seemed to so far anyway. The listing isn’t smart enough. They have been useful though when the come up on the movie pages themselves… If I liked that movie maybe someone has already complied a list of similar films.

    Btw: I still get most of my new picks from my watching what my friends queue up.

    ReplyDelete
  39. On Privacy:

    Baf has a point about public ratings, I can see why a lot of people would want to keep them private. Yet you can’t simply not rate them, as someone seemed to suggest, if you also want the full value of the Netflix system. Default should be that all ratings are private unless you want to join in on the community side of things and reset your preferences to specifically reflect that.


    For Michael on Privacy

    You said: “Baff is correct. Because rating history is different from rental history, and because the information is only attached to an anonymous profile (and because you can opt out entirely by "not participating in community features") the decision of whether to show only 5-star ratings, or more, is purely a gut call.”

    The whole thing seems to be working backwards. In order to protect the bulk of the members (Mom for example) all community features should be opt-in. (And as we do go and opt-in it should be clear exactly how that information is going to be used or made public so I can opt out of each feature as necessary.) As I understand it if I want Netflix to recommend good movies I have to rate them… just because I rate them doesn’t mean I want everyone to see what movies I rate. Just because I write a review, doesn’t meant I want people to have access to that list either. As more and more community features are rolled out the problem of keeping track of how Netflix is handling or mishandling our privacy is only going to get worse. Netflix should be extremely conservative about how it handles it’s customers privacy the fact that you are splitting legal hairs to justify a ‘gut call’ isn’t going to give people much confidence. Especially since the feature your talking about only amounts to something cool but not essential. Like others have said here the more loosey-goosey and slippery a company is about protecting privacy the lest their customers and potential customers trust them. You can still do all sorts of neat cool stuff and maintain a rock solid, compact, easy and reliable privacy policy.

    For Amanda on Privacy

    “But I find it difficult to understand why someone would want to keep their ratings private when no one could possibly know who you are.”

    You don’t have to understand it, they just do. First because there is always the chance that someone could identify you, or knows or find out your username from home or work anyway. Second because anyone who’s ever maintained a ‘virtual’ representation of themselves fully understands that those representations are still in effect you. An extension of you, but you non-the-less. Controlling how you are presented, and protecting your privacy is still important whether it’s a username in your favorite forum, a character in an online game, or your own name and information in real life. It’s all connected and it’s all still you.

    From another Anon: “The information we see about reviewers is not that invasive “

    Yet… maybe… Some disagree… but the discussion has been already to open up all the ratings. And then what’s next? We just can’t know…

    After all, that is why people have responded so well to the private settings for movies, because they don’t want their family and friends to see absolutely everything they rent. The way they handled the e-mail issue with ‘friends notes’ is another indication that perhaps Netflix isn’t yet as aggressive in protecting privacy as they should be. (A right to privacy includes a right to be left alone and not bothered.) Even if you extend ‘Movie Privacy’ to ratings, it’s a lot to ask of over 6 million members to go through and remember to set all their rated/queued/watched movies to private. We shouldn’t be placed in a position where we have to scour the entire site every few months to make sure we haven’t been opted into some new community feature because we wrote one review last year or have a couple friends. Trust is earned and I’m not so sure I can trust Netflix in the future judging by what’s happened so far. The “ill” that comes of all this is that Netflix has rolled out features that erode privacy unbeknownst to members. The “ill” is that these features are no longer used by many members because of these issues, when an alternative design could have made them useful to everyone. The “ill” is that Netflix will loose the trust of more and more of its members weakening the company and thereby the services they can provide us.

    Amanda,

    “Participating in community features (by having a public profile) would just opt you in to showing all ratings by default. If Netflix sets it up as such, you could still opt-out, specifically, of showing all ratings if that really bothers you.”

    Only if it’s clear what having a public profile means when you set one up. There’s nothing wrong, and everything right, with being explicit and thorough. Right now I wouldn’t know all the places I’d have to check to handle my privacy settings. They should all be in one easy to find place and state clearly what they each do and don’t do. When you first load your profile page (assuming our privacy settings are gathered there) your default should be private on every setting. You should have to decide exactly what features you opt-into and what information to make public, under what circumstances and where. That is the only way to be clear and sure that any particular member had an opportunity to know EXACTLY what they were signing up for.

    Robert,

    “…but I think we can take Netflix at their word as regards the Privacy Setting…”

    No ‘we’ can’t, because they keep changing how things work and show no signs that this will change for whatever they roll out in the future. And regardless of weather ‘you’ trust them… a lot of people who are unaware of what is going on in community development might be more than a little concerned if they did know. If Netflix were being truly aggressive about protecting customer privacy then I’d be more comfortable making a statement like that too.

    ReplyDelete
  40. ovie taste by looking at their 5-star rating only. I've rated more than 1,500 movies, and I pity anyone who'd be presented with all of them. I don't much care for the Top 10 lists (they all seem to be the same lists whenever I log on) and the "other members like you"-section has so far only disappointed me. These people who are supposedly like me, do not rate like

    ReplyDelete